A NEW SET DHT AURAL MATRIX
MENNO VAN DE VEEN’S
PLITRON’S SET TORROID OPT BREAKTHROUGH

Let’s face it gents, we are the thermionic green berets: a small group of dedicated fierce warriors ready to go anywhere and do anything to accomplish our mission. Because we are the vanguard of the audio revolution we know more about the edge of the audio arts for a good reason.... we are creating it. Because Karma rules, we, the throbbing phallus of the audio arts, are rewarded for our work. It is our job to question and challenge every conventional notion about design and continue to experiment. I remind you of my experiments with making interconnects and speaker cables with Radio Shack ultra-thin magnet wire and solid silver wire...which was exactly opposite of what everyone else was doing. So it is our job to question and experiment.

According to audio orthodoxy torroid output transformers don’t work well. It is also well known that DHT SETs don’t work well. I also want to suggest that all vinyl systems don’t work well. You might say that they only things that sound really juicy are those things that don’t work well....according to the bogus audio orthodoxy. So let us be skeptical about torroid OPTs, but the only thing we can trust is our heightened sense of music.

During the 1970s when I had to own every tube amplifier ever made, I bought a pair of Gotham Audio cutting head amplifiers just because they had the rara avis... torroid output transformers. Soon after that I was shown pictures of the David Hafler “never manufactured” torroid OPT Dynaco MkIVs, and that is the last I heard about torroid output transformers. Have you ever seen any tube amp with big round OPT? Probably not, because the orthodoxy is that torroid OPTs have a “family” of electrical problems that make them unsuitable for high quality audio.

Of course we all know how torroid power transformers and chokes have distinct advantages and are much appreciated....and more and more SET triode bros’ are using torroid OPTs

In December I was contacted by Menno van de Veen ( a serious Dutch thermionic techno-shaman who has written a great book on tube amplifier design available from Plitron and a dude I first made contact with at New York Audio Labs) who designs torroids of all sorts for Plitron Manufacturing in Canada. Menno was surfing the Triode Guild web site and wanted me to know that he had developed a new torroid OPT for single-ended circuits, and claimed that he had overcome many of the limitations of the torroid OPT “orthodoxy” and believed that his new design had significant performance advantages. Was I interested? Which is like asking me if I would you like to take a shower with Cameron Diaz? I suggested that he send me a pair of 5K models for 300Bs (Please remember that my hunt, as Guildmeister, is for the musical shadows that surround notes, and not power. My formula is 5K transformers, at about 360 Volts at 60 ma in SETs), and was informed that it would be a few months before the first were available, so I waited. The idea of being one of the first to hear a SET torroid output amp was potentially very colossally cool.

I then emailed my thermionic techno-shamans brothers around the world and asked if anyone had any experience with single-ended torroid OPTs and no one had a clue...not even the lofty Sir Scott Frankland. In other words, Menno had created the first of its kind. By this time I received lots of technical papers from Menno explaining his breakthrough which was so technical that I didn’t understand most of it. According to Howard Gladstone president of Plitron, this SET OPT has been a two year project.

What I find so interesting about Menno’s design work is that he wrestles with OUR essential artistic paradox: to a serious audio engineer DHT-SETs don’t make any sense, and from their oscilloscope point of view they are right. To those who live by their ears, and not by their oscilloscope, DHT-SETs make profound sense because they produce such rich triode cream, and we wonder why engineers love their push/pull amplifiers. Don’t they want to cream more economically and dance naked in the stars?

But Menno is a righteous cool dude, and he recognizes that something is going on in the world wide craze for DHT-SETs, and is working to design a “better” OPT meaning.... wider bandwidth, more linear and one with better transient response, and one that interfaces with the speaker load with less variation.....recognizing the positively prehistoric nature of the circuits we love. Never forget this: When it comes to musical beauty YOU know best.

A QUICKIE SURPRISE

At 7:00 PM on December 14, 1999 I heated my soldering iron and put my custom 300B SET on the operating table, and in about fifteen minutes my “normal” output transformer was disconnected the Plitron unit rigged. The other amp stayed stock. My comparison was made with the KR 300BXL tubes.

I am so vain that I think this song is about me, but quite frankly it doesn’t take much on my system to discern differences in gizmos. After only listening for 30 minutes my initial impression is that Menno and Plitron have been very successful and.... the transformer hadn’t aged in yet, and I didn’t even experiment to find its “sweet spot”.

These were my quickie responses: bass response like the Sun push/pull and the tonal quality of the Tamura iron....but not quite. Better high frequency response and a very wide soundstage than all of the other SET OPT I have in my collection.

After months of listening I am asserting that all of those who are insisting that torroid OPTs, and especially the ones for SETs, don’t work properly need a serious attitude adjustment....at least the Plitron design. So let me make the point plain: Menno’s design creates a unique aural matrix that is extremely creamy, but it is a completely different form of SET cream, and that is what is so exciting about it. Don’t ask me now to compare the micro to the macro cream or give you the details about the torroid cream’s harmonic or how wide it is. The difference between torroids and some of best American made iron is substantial, and you should own at least a pair of each.

Let me tell you the bad news: these are big round mothers and probably can’t be fitted to your existing amplifier which means you have to build a new chassis to accommodate them.

Are torroid OPTs the answer to staying refined while using those higher current DHTs? Are torroids the secret of getting more of those push/pull aural matrix benefits without push/pull’s aural discombobularities? And what happens when we use the 2A3, and 45 with torroid OPTs? MY ANSWER IS THAT THESE ARE TRULY SIGNIFICANT ACHIEVEMENTS.

And what about ‘REINVENTING PUSH/PULL”? What about a push/pull 300B amplifier with torroid OPTs? I don’t know yet!

How do these compare in quality to the new SET OPT designs that I have received? I prefer the Plitrons.

Are they as good as the the Japanese Masterpieces? They are very different. They are more alive, bombastic, full of musical juice. They are not as refined harmonically, and they don’t have that magical inter note silence, but they do a magnificent dance. They make the Western Electric 300Bs come to life, in a way that no other SET OPT has achieved.

I have asked Howard Gladstone, President of Plitron and Menno to put together a new “understandable” information package about their torroid OPTs and that will be available soon, so get on the waiting list.

For more information contact Plitron at their email address: techinfo@plitron.com

Web site: www.plitron.com

 

 

 

Back to The Triode Guild               Back to Meta-Gizmo   

e-mail Dr. Harvey "Gizmo" Rosenberg: drgizmo@meta-gizmo.com

Copyright© 2005    Meta-Gizmo.com™ and Dr. Harvey "Gizmo" Rosenberg      All rights reserved.
All the material contained within the above articles may not be reproduced without his express permission.